Key differences on Cost & aid
- 1
John Carroll's grants cover 53% of its full price on average, vs. 47% at Messiah
Aid generosity - 2
Messiah costs about $1.7K less per year on average than John Carroll ($30,194 vs. $31,925, all students)
Average cost, all students
Cost & aid
Cost & aid
Average cost, aid generosity, net price by family income, sticker prices, and grants.
What students pay
Grants
Sticker prices
On one scale, so the bars read against each other.
Up to $110K: the average net price per year for students receiving federal aid, 2023–24; families who didn't file the FAFSA aren't included. Above it the published data end. For your own number, use the college's net price calculator .
Family income per year $150K
- MessiahLittle need-based aid above $110K
Merit possible (proxy); averaging $20K
- John CarrollPublished data end at $110K
Merit possible (proxy); averaging $31K
Published (federal figure, up to $110K) EstimateBars share one scale: the largest full price.
Where need-based aid ends, merit, and published promises
| Metric | Messiah | John Carroll |
|---|---|---|
| Need-based aid up to | Little need-based aid above $110K | Published data end at $110K |
| Merit for students without need | 31% got a grant without federal aid, averaging $20K (proxy) | 30% got a grant without federal aid, averaging $31K (proxy) |
| Published promise | – | – |
A college's own promise is stated for a typical family and changes yearly; where a promise and our estimate disagree, the promise wins. Merit has no income limit, so it can lower the price above the point where need-based aid ends.
Tuition guarantee & Promise program
| Metric | Messiah | John Carroll |
|---|---|---|
| Tuition guarantee | No | No |
| Promise program | Yes | No |
From the colleges' Common Data Sets
| Metric | Messiah | John Carroll |
|---|---|---|
| Aid forms | FAFSA | – |
| Aid priority date or deadline | April 1 (priority) | – |
| Need met, first-years | 82% | – |
| Average aid package, first-years | $38,388 | – |
| College grant dollars given as merit | – | – |
| Aid for international students | Offered | – |
Sources:IPEDS Institutional Characteristics survey, 2023–24;IPEDS Student Financial Aid survey, 2023–24;College Scorecard, 2023–24;Messiah University Common Data Set 2025–26, Fall 2026 entrants;Messiah University Common Data Set 2025–26, 2025–26 (estimated);College Scorecard, most recent release;Common Data Set, most recent release;Messiah University Common Data Set 2025–26, 2025–26About the data(retrieved 2026-10-12)
Figures are the newest each college has published; years can differ between colleges. Each value's ⓘ shows its source and year. Why