Quad

Key differences on Students & campus

  1. 1

    Messiah is more diverse (index 0.42 vs. 0.36)

    Diversity index
  2. 2

    John Carroll has 1 pts more Pell recipients than Messiah (21% vs. 20%)

    Pell Grant recipients
  3. 3

    John Carroll has 0 pts more first-gen students than Messiah (19% vs. 18%)

    First-generation students

Students

Students & campus

Who's on each campus, how many get Pell Grants or are the first in their family, and campus life.

Who's on campus

Undergrads
Messiah2.3K
John Carroll2.3K
Pell Grant share
Messiah20%
John Carroll21%
First-gen share
Messiah18%
John Carroll19%
Diversity index
Messiah0.42
John Carroll0.36

Who they are

Men
Messiah43%
John Carroll54%
Part-time students
Messiah2%
John Carroll2%
Students 25 and older
Messiah2%
John Carroll1%

Race & ethnicity

Messiah
John Carroll
  • White
  • Asian
  • Hispanic/Latino
  • Black
  • Two or more
  • International
  • Other/unknown

Where they're from

First-years from in state
Messiah66%
John Carroll69%
First-years from other states
Messiah33%
John Carroll31%
First-years from abroad
Messiah1%
John Carroll0%
New transfer students this fall
Messiah78
John Carroll125
Transfers, share of new undergraduates
Messiah12%
John Carroll17%

Campus

Messiah
Large suburbNCAA D-III · Middle Atlantic States Athletic CorporationROTCStudy abroad
John Carroll
Large suburbNCAA D-III · North Coast Athletic ConferenceROTCStudy abroadUndergrad research

LGBTQ+ policies

Each item is dated: either the college's own page, checked on that date, or a national list's claim, read on that date — never a plain “yes” or “no.” A key missing for a college isn't shown as “no”: nothing was found for it.

All student numbers in the table

Sources:College Scorecard, Fall 2024;College Scorecard, most recent release;College Scorecard, Fall 2023;IPEDS Fall Enrollment survey (part C, residence of first-time students), Fall 2024;IPEDS Fall Enrollment survey (part A, enrollment by level), Fall 2024;IPEDS directory (Institutional Characteristics: HD), 2025–26;IPEDS Institutional Characteristics survey, 2023–24;IPEDS Institutional Characteristics survey (athletics, programs, services, religious affiliation), 2025–26About the data(retrieved 2026-10-12)

Figures are the newest each college has published; years can differ between colleges. Each value's ⓘ shows its source and year. Why